‹ Back

InternatIonal ChIld AbductIon In Turkey: A Legal GuIde on The Hague ConventIon and Return to HabItual ResIdence

For a parent, the unauthorized removal or retention of a child by the other spouse is a nightmare scenario. When a child is wrongfully taken from their habitual residence to another country—or retained in Turkey after a scheduled visitation—it is not merely a custody dispute; it is a complex international legal matter governed by strict treaties.

As Maya Law Firm, we specialize in international child abduction cases and the legal processes for the return of the child to their habitual residence (mutat mesken). This guide outlines the legal framework in Turkey, the role of the Hague Convention, and recent precedents from the Turkish Court of Cassation (Yargıtay).

1. The Legal Framework: The Hague Convention and Turkish Law

Turkey is a signatory to the 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction. In Turkish domestic law, this is implemented through Law No. 5717 (Uluslararası Çocuk Kaçırmanın Hukuki Yön ve Kapsamına Dair Kanun).

The primary objective of this legal framework is simple but urgent: to secure the prompt return of children wrongfully removed to or retained in any Contracting State.

Unlike a standard divorce or custody case, a "Return Case" does not decide who is the "better" parent. Instead, it answers a jurisdictional question: Where should the custody battle take place? The answer is almost always the child's country of habitual residence.

2. What is "Habitual Residence"?

In Turkish courts, Habitual Residence (Mutat Mesken) is a factual concept, not a technical one based solely on citizenship. It refers to the place where the child has established the center of their life—where they go to school, have friends, and live their daily life immediately before the abduction occurred.

If your child’s habitual residence is abroad (e.g., Germany, UK, USA) and they have been wrongfully brought to Turkey, Turkish Family Courts have the authority to order their immediate return under the Convention.

3. The Return Process in Turkey

Under Law No. 5717, the process typically involves the following steps:

1. Application to Central Authority: The left-behind parent must apply to the Central Authority (Ministry of Justice) in their own country or directly to the Turkish Ministry of Justice.

2. Involvement of the Public Prosecutor: In Turkey, the lawsuit is technically filed by the Public Prosecutor (Cumhuriyet Savcısı) on behalf of the Central Authority. However, the left-behind parent is the core party to the dispute and must be represented by an experienced child abduction lawyer to ensure their rights are actively defended.

3. Speed is Crucial: The Convention mandates that these cases be handled expeditiously. If a case takes longer than six weeks, authorities may be asked to explain the delay.

4. Defenses Against Return: The "Grave Risk" Exception

The abducting parent often tries to prevent the return by citing Article 13(b) of the Convention, claiming that returning the child would expose them to physical or psychological harm.

However, Turkish Courts interpret this exception very strictly. The mere fact that the child is happy in Turkey, or that the mother/father has better living conditions here, is not sufficient grounds to refuse return.

5. Recent Precedents: What Does the Turkish Supreme Court Say?

At Maya Law Firm, we closely monitor the latest decisions of the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation) to build winning strategies for our clients. Recent rulings from 2024 highlight the court's strict adherence to the Convention:

• Adaptation is Not Enough: In a recent decision (Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber, 2024/8322 E., 2024/8168 K.), the Court ruled that even if the child says they love the abducting parent or have adapted to the new environment, this does not constitute a "grave risk." The Court ordered the return of children to their habitual residence in the UK, emphasizing that the abducting parent cannot benefit from their wrongful act.

• The Age Limit: The Convention applies only to children under the age of 16. As confirmed in decision 2024/5180 E., once a child turns 16 during the proceedings, the Convention no longer applies.

• Role of Experts: The court must obtain reports from psychologists or social workers to assess specific risks, but these reports must focus on "grave risk," not on custody preferences (Yargıtay 2024/4977 E.).

6. Why You Need an Expert Lawyer

International child abduction cases are legally technical. A lawyer who treats this like a standard divorce case may fail to grasp the nuances of Law No. 5717 and the Hague Convention.

At Maya Law Firm, we provide:

• Immediate Action: We understand that time is critical.

• Central Authority Coordination: We manage the complex communication between Ministries.

• Expert Representation: We ensure the court focuses on the "wrongful removal" and not irrelevant custody arguments.

If your child has been wrongfully removed to Turkey or taken from Turkey to another country, contact us immediately. We are ready to fight for your child's right to return home.